I think that it is a trap. I think this because what if E got there and got them. JB wouldn't be able to help them. Who knows where he is? If I was in Jonahs shoes I would probably be doing the same thing he is right now. I would be wondering if the government or the FBI were in everything and I would be panicking. I wouldn't go to the thing that they were going to. I don't think that it matters if it is sponsored by the county it matters if it's safe.
Makayla Shawcroft I think that this is a trap because weird have been going in the book since Angela left. None of the Dupre people have never even heard of Angela Dupre. Also when Chip and the others went to Robin's Egg Lane they met a woman that said that the house that Daniella said she was going to move into was a house that had been empty for a long time. If I was in there shoes first I would try to first remember all the facts that I could about James Reardon because it seems that he is included in this whole mess because he seemed to know were the people were going to be move before the people even knew they were going move. Then Chip figures out a pattern that all the adoptions kids. They are all now located in Upper Tyson, Clarksville, and Liston which happen to be the areas that the kids can come and talk adoption in a meeting. Then after I thought about all that I think that I would probably go because maybe I could figure out E's plans or I could tell the other survivors the latest updates on what has happened.
In my opinion, I think it would be a trap because of the way Mr. Hodge deals with the kids. If I were in Jonah's place right now, I would run away from the adoption place with Katherine and Chip to find out where E is and what he's trying to do with his plans, and if Angela is with E. Then I would track down Angela to see if she is alright and in good condition. As for the parents, they could go home or they would probable follow me Katherine and Chip.
I think it is a trap, because Mr.Hodge picked out the kids on the survivor list. He also picked out 36 kids. This could mean that he is trying to kidnap the kids or kill them. I believe that Mr.Hodge is E. Or maybe someone who E works with. But I still believe my theory about E being good. So maybe this man is against E. Trying to sabotage everything. If I was Jonah, I would try to pick up sharp rocks on my way to the picnic. So I would have a little to defend myself, if anything happened. If I saw anything suspicious, I would try to contact 911 as soon as possible. But I would try to keep low key as well. Because maybe if I stay close to Mr.Hodge I might find useful information
In my opinion, I think it would be a trap because of the way Mr. Hodge handles the kids. He picked out 36 kids on the survival list. I would think that he would harm them. I would not trust them.
I think that it is a trap,and Mr. Hodge could be working with E. Plus, he gathered up all of the children that were on the plane. I think that Mr. Hodge may kidnap them, because he shut the doors, possibly locking them. This separates the children from their parents. That means that if they get kidnapped, there would be no one to save them. I think that if I were in that situation, I would play it cool until I find out what was going to happen. I of course would be scared on the inside, I just wouldn't show it.
Dakota Sasser I think it is a trap to. but I have a theory. I think e sent the notes to lead them in to a trap. Back to the subject. If I was in there shoes I whould be peronoid be couse I don't know who sent it.
Abril Ugalde From my reading, I know that they possibly have every single kid that was on that plane 13 years ago other than the girl Katherine replaced. I do think that it is a trap, I just do not know what the trap is. What could they possibly do with 36 13-year-old kids and come up with an explanation? If I were in Jonah's shoes, would slowly walk away with Chip and Katherine. I would hide so they couldn't see me and watch what they were doing. If things got out of hand and it was a trap, I would sprint back with Chip and Katherine to warn all of the adults.
Addison Hollister I do not think it is a trap. I think it is just a coincidence that the babies were in the same group, maybe they're not even the same babies from the plane. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would be scared, but not of the fact that the babies on the plane are in the same group, but of everything else going on around me. I wouldn't show it, because you would need to stay calm for Chip and Katherine so they don't start freaking out and panicking.
Parker Jones I think it is a trap. I think that Mr. Hodge is going to kidnap the kids that he called into the lobby. Jonah is in a panic because his sister is in the other group of kids and not with him and Chip. I think Jonah is going to try and get Katherine out of the other group and into the same group as his so they can be together. If I were in Jonah’s shoes I would want Katherine to be with me too. I would also try to get all of us kids back to our parents before something bad happens to us by Mr. Hodge or Carol.
In my opinion I think it is a trap.I think that Mr.Hodge sent the letter to kidnap of of the kids on the survivor list.If I were in Jonah shoes I would want Katherine to go to the other group.I would not think it would just be a cowincadence that all the survivors are inthe same group.
From my reading, I think it is a trap because Mr. Hodge had every kid on the survivors list. I think that he might be working with "E" and he is planned on taking all those kids back to their time. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would act, I would ask Mr. Hodge what we're doing. I would have asked what our plans for the day were. I think that everyone there works for, or with, "E". I think that Mr. Hodge or Carol is going to try and get the kids to leave the school so they can send them back to their time.
Yes I think it is a trap to get all the kids from the plane together for E. If i was in Jonahs shoes i would probably follow them and on any sign of trouble i would turn around and run. I also think that they sent the letters to them. Also that they also are trying to send them back to there time.
Casamaro White Based on what I read, I believe it is a trap ever since Angela left more things have went down hill than normal. The Dupree's have never even heard of Angela Dupree is what surprises me most. I also think that Mr.Hodge is helping E because he had every kid on the survivors list. Also that they will both take all the survivors back to their time. Jonah is in a panic right now because his sister is in another group of kids and not with him and Chip. I have a feeling Jonah might sneak out of his group to get Katherine and bring her to his group. If I was in Jonah's shoes I would be doing a lot of the same things he is doing right now. I would go get Katherine to stay with me in my group just in case something bad happens. I would also try to sneak to the door and open it for the parents to see if anything bad happens they can step in.
Taylor Alvarez I do not believe the conference is a trap. I do not think it is a trap because there are other adopted kids there. I do think that Katherine should not have pretended to be Daniella McCarthy. I think she will get caught if they ask her questions only the real Daniella knows the answers too. That is part of the reason why Jonah has panicked. If I was in his shoes I would just keep quiet and go along with the conference but I would be panicking too. I would be hopeful that Katherine has a plan and that all goes okay.
I think that the conference is a trap. Some people are very sneaky like they can knock someone out in one punch with other people in the room without them even noticing. If I was in Jonah's shoes I would call the police. (if they will rely on me).
Lily Pinson To be honest, I do think that it is a trap. I think this because at the end of chapter twenty-five, they had almost all of the babies from the plane. In my opinion, I think that this could be the point where they had all been rushed into a time traveler that could disguise itself as anything you could think of and go back in time. Yes I do think that the time traveler that the babies were on could disguise itself as anything you could imagine. Although, if I were in Jonah's shoes, I would want to run away with Katherine and Chip. I would not care who these people were. All that I would know is that these are people that I don't know, and that they seem suspicious and I should get out of there as soon as possible. I would let the police know where other kids are located with no supervision of any other adult what so ever. I would want to make sure that all of the other kids would be safe from harms way.
Johnanthony Hallberg I think its a trap because mr.Hodge is probably going to kidnap all the children on the survivors list. And the reason I think that he will kidnap them is he is working with "E" so "E" can do what he wants with them. Also if I was in Jonas shoes I would run away with chip and katherine. and ones I got away I would call the police and tell them where I am and what happened. and ones I was safe I would retrace my steps and see if I could find out where they went
Brielle Johnson I think that the conference is a trap. Ever sense the meeting with Angela things have been weird. Mr. Hodge and CarolI think is helping E because all the kids on the survivors list is there. The Depres didn't know Angela. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would act. I would go ask Mr. Hodge what they were going to be doing. As I was walking around I would try to find things to defend myself incase something happened.
Lainey Hyde I think that the meeting is a trap because there where all 36 kids from the plane at the meeting. What are the odds of that happening. If I where in Jonah's shoes I would have gone to the meeting but made my mom and dad stay so if it was a trap they could do something. In conclusion, I do think that the meeting is a trap.
Thane Horton Yes I think that conference is a trap. I believe this because, all 36 of the survivors are there with Mr.Hodge and none with Carol. I think Mr.Hodge and Carol work with E. It has also been weird since the meeting with Angela. If I was Jonah I would group up with Chip and Kathrine to talk to all the kids.
Rafe Card I think it is a trap. It is a trap because they are going to get kidnapped with E and Hodge. They are with all the 36 survivors together. This seems really fishy because the people with carol are not any of the 36 people that where in the plane.
I think it is a trap. I think it is a trap because they have all thirty-six kids there together. I think that they are going to take them somewhere and show them where they came from. This confrence is not an adoption confrence. This is going to show them who they really are.
I do think that this is a trap. I think it is a trap because they ALL got the letters and I think that they are ALL being asked to go. If I was Jonah I would not go. I would stay home with Chip and Katherine and see what happens if they do not go.
Evelyn O’Neill From reading chapters 23, 24, and 25 I think that it is a trap and they could get hurt. If I was in Jonah’s shoes I would not done all that he has. If I did something wrong I know that JB would help me. If I did do everything that he did I would be more and more into it.
John Rowe I think that it is going to end up being a trap. I think that E is going to be there and try to get info from them just like at the library. If I was in Jonah's shoes, I would have told them that something didn't feel right, and that they had to leave that place before something bad happens. If I were Jonah, I would have been alert and ready to act too.
I believe that this is a trap. Its very odd that while Jonah, Chip, and Katherine are trying to look in the adoption stuff, and then a paper shows up for adoptees to figure out their identity. Another thing that is very odd is that the guides made all of the kids on the Survivors list. What I think gives the guides away the most is that each kid has to touch a certain part of a rock, which is supposedly a hand scanner to make sure you are who you say you are. If I were Jonah, I would have been ready to act and I would also be more alert than he is.
Clayton Rigney Things are getting a little scary. I do think it could be a trap. But it also is a perfect time for Jonah and Chip to get information from all the kids on the list. If I were in Jonah's shoes I'd get all the information as fast as I could.
I think it's a trap! Why would it happen to only be in the three towns of the survivors? It can't be a coincidence that it's for adopted children and the children of those specific towns only. I think they need to warn someone about this meeting such as the police or Jonah's parents.
I think that it is a trap that all of the children were put together in a group. I think that the E will be coming in the next couple of events. If I were in his shoes, I too would be stressed. I think that even though he might be stressed or panicked he should stay.
Zowie Anderson I think that it is a trap because E might be sponsoring it. I think that it was for Upper Tyson, Clarksville, and Liston and those are all where the survivors adopted kids moved too. So I think that E is going to try and kidnap or do something with the kids that are adopted.
Graycee Tibbals I think it is a trap.I think this because what if the E went there and got them.JB wouldn't be able to help them.Who knows where he is?If I was in Jonahs shoes I would probably would be doing the same thing right now.I would be wondering if the government or the FBI where in everything.I would want to go to where they are going.I don't care if it is sponserd by the county or to be safe.
Tylie Norcutt I think it is all a trap. If I were in Jonahs shoes I would be freaking out. I would be wondering what is going to happen next. I would also be wondering who all know about this. Is it just the FBI or does the government know too.
I believe that it is a trap. If I was in Jonah's shoes I would be calm ant thinking of a way to escape or just think of a way to shut it down or fight it. I think that the F.B.I set it up because Mr.Reardon figured out that Jonah had taken pictures and met with Angela and he was trying to stop Jonah. I also wander if JB knows about it so he can go help Jonah, Chip, and Kathrine.
I feel that it is a trap for a couple of reasons. One reason is that Angela said there were thirty-six babies on the plane and Katherine said that Mr. Hodge called 36 kids in his group and Katherine told Jonah they were all the kids on the plane. I don't think that it's a coincidence that all 36 of the kids on the plane are in the same group. E or someone is plotting something. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would try to maintain myself and figure out a plan in case something really was going to happen. I would also be asking all the kids questions about any strange events that had been happening lately.
Levi Johnson I think it's a trap and that if I were in his shoes I would scared and nervous. I would do a couple of things. First I would learn some sort of defense skill. Second thing I would do is keep watch of every body and make sure one tries to capture me.
I do think it is a trap because it is no coincidence that Mr. Hodge called all thirty-six kids that were on the plane in his group. I also think it is a trap because I think Mr. Hodge is E. I think this because Mr. Hodge wouldn’t call all thirty-six kids on the survivors list in his group; he would only call all of them if he wanted to get them all together to do something to them. If I was in Jonah’s shoes, I would stay close to Katherine and Chip to make sure that we all stay together. Also, I would make sure that we are all protected by one another. Another thing I would do is stay at the back of the line so if Mr. Hodge tries to do something to us; Katherine, Chip and I could get away.
I think it is a trap, it's kind of weird that Mr. Hodge called thirty-six kids up to his group and there was thirty-six babies on the plane. I think that Mr. Hodge is E, and if he was I would try to get everyone out of there (including the kids I don’t know.) If I were Jonah I would send Katherine into the other group just in case anything happens she would not be involved. But then yet again Katherine would probably refuse and come with us any way.
Carter Paul I think it is a trap, because Mr. Hodge picked out the kids on the survivor list. He also picked out 36 kids. This could mean that he is trying to kidnap the kids or kill them. I believe that Mr. Hodge is E. Or maybe someone who E works with. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would have gone to the meeting but made my mom and dad stay so if it was a trap they could do something.
Avery Paul Based on what I read, I think that it is a trap and they could get hurt. If I was in Jonah’s shoes I would not done all that he has. If I did something wrong I know that JB would help me. If I did do everything that he did I would be more and more into it.
According to the text, Mr. Hodge called up thirty-six children. It isn't just a coincidence that that happens to be the number of babies on the plane. I think that Mr. Hodge is E and that all of this is a trap! What if he is planning to take them back to the future, or even harm them physically? If I were Jonah, I would make sure I was as far away from Mr. Hodge as possible, and close to Katherine and Chip. This could be a life or death situation. Who knows what his parents would be thinking?
Kennadee Irving I completely think that is a trap. There is 36 kids on the plane and 36 kids in the line. All the kids on the survivors list got called into the same line. I mean it can’t be a coincidence. Mr. Hodge is probably an accomplice of “E”. Kathrine, Chip, and Jonah are walking straight into a trap.
Jarrett Peek Based on what I have read I think that it is a trap because Mr. Hodge picked out all of the kids on the survivors list. There were also 36 babies on the plane and there are 36 kids in line. I think that Mr. Hodge is E or works with E.
Aubrey Vaughn I think that it's a trap. Just because the government held the event doesn't mean that the event was safe. It's a trap because all thirty-six kids were in the same group. If I was in Jonah's shoes I would have gone. I would know something was wrong. I would also panic because I know that Mr. Hodge is E.
Jessalyn Lewis From my reading I believe that it is a trap. I believe that it is a trap because in the text it said “ Angela said that there were thirty-six babies on the plane. I think Mr. Hodge called out thirty-six names.” This tells me that someone had planned to have all thirty-six of the kids in one group. Since they are all in one group, people like E can do whatever they want with the kids. If I were in Jonah’s shoes right now, I don’t think that I would feel any different then he does right now. I would find a reason to leave and hide until three o’clock.
I think that could be a trap. Or the gathering of all these kids has some purpose. If I was Jonah, I would feel scared and panicked that something might happen. I believe that they will find out the information they need to solve the mystery.
From my reading, by now to me it seems obvious it's a trap based upon how the 3 kids (Mostly Katherine) thought that it possibly could be a trap. Back tracking a bit, 36 babies were on the palne. Mr. Hodge called out 36 names, names of kids that are all adopted, half of them on the survivors list they got pictures of. At this point in the book, everything is comming together. If I was in the situation Jonah was in I wouldn't know what to do, but I know I would definetly not be as courageous as him. I'd rather curl up in a corner and scream until someone did something. Maybe that's not a good thing but I do not have enough courage at all to do something like with Jonah did.
Preston Kelsey Thinking about what I read I think it is a trap. They want all 36 kids in one place. If they are all trapped in one place E can do almost anything to them. I would feel panicked and scared like Jonah is in the book. E is a stranger and strangers can be dangerous as I had said before. If I were Jonah I would want to go and face the challenge, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't feel very scared. I like what John Wayne said about courage. "Courage is being scared to death and saddling up anyway."
I think it is a trap. I thought that it was strange that they called thirty six names including the ones on the list. If I were in Jonah’s shoes, I would be panicking. In my head I would be thinking that James Reardon and E are going to pop out and take all the kids. I’m sure that this is what the letters were warning them about.
Chapter 23,24,25 RUBY HISKETT I believe the whole thing is a trap. One of the people managing the whole thing could actually be E. If I was Jhona I would actually shutting the whole thing down. I would not want to go to a big convention and meet people that I didn't even know. If I was Jhona I would also be freaking out as well, all of this would be very scary to me.
I really think that it is a trap because there was 36 kids on the plane and thirty six kids in a list so it has to be a trap. If I were Jonah I would also be freaking out. I would also try to cancel this entire thing. I would think that Mr.Readon and E are going to try and seek all of the kids to the future. Over all, if I were Jonah I would be very scared and would not want to go on.
Based on what I read I think it is a trap. First there were 36 seats on the plane and there are 36 kids in a group all being on the plane besides Katherine. I think Jonah isn't ready to act yet. if i was in his shoes I would have tried to slip away from the group and get to my parents before something bad happened.I would be very scared too.
Zane Felton Based on information I got from these chapters, I would be a little suspicious about the event. Either way, I would still go to the event to find more answers. I would really think it would be a trap when 36 kids including me would be put in a group. Like Angela stated at the library, there were 36 seats on the plane. At that point if I was in Jonah's shoes, I'd panic.
Ava Ekins-Faught Based on what I read, it sounds like a trap. There were thirty-six babies on a plane and now there are thirty-six kids that are all adopted in the same group, and they are also all on the survivors list. When Chip, Katherine, and Jonah were at the library Angela said that she thought that there were from the future. She also said there were thirty-six seats on the plane. If I were Jonah I would be worried.
Bryce Adams From what I have read it does sound like a trap. Mr. Hodge could be working with E. There was 36 babies on the plane but, Mr. Hodge called 36 kids to the plane. I would ask the kids if anything has been going on that has been weird.
According to my reading I think that it is a trap. It is the perfect set up to have. I think that one of the people who manages could be E. If I were Jonah I would be nervous. I would be putting myself in danger and not knowing what was going to happen and in that situation I would be very nervous.
I think that it is a trap. It is a possibility that Mr. Hodge could be working with “E”. If It was me I would also have a panic feeling. I would to get more information before I did anything. Other than that I would pretty much do the same thing as Jonah.
Sofia Utz I believe this is a trap. I think this because the only people he called were most likely all the people on the plane. I also think this because if you remember all the letters, one of them read "Beware! They're coming back to get you!", and this situation seems like the perfect time to retrieve all the people of the people on the train. If i was in Jonah's shoes, I would follow along, just to see what would really happen, though this can be a bad idea because it could get to where i can't escape, I would try this just to see what would happen.
Gabby Stiehl In my opinion I think this is a trap. I think it's a trap because if Katherine's theory that all 36 babies were separated into the same group, it must be because Mr. Hodge is working with E. If I were Jonah I would be scared and confused. I would probably want to just go home and forget about the whole situation. I think Jonah should just sit back, stay quiet and observe.
I think it is a trap because Mr. Hodge almost called all 36 kids to be in his group from the survivals list or from the witness list. If I was Jonah right now I would try to be prepared for anything that is going to happen next. Another thing I might do is scream or run for my life if something bad is happening. I would do this if I were Jonah because I want to be cautious but scared and frightened. Chip, Jonah, and, Katherine doesn’t know where Mr. Hodge and Gary are taking them and far they will go plus how long they are going to take to go there stay and go back. It might be a trap because when they met Mr. Hodge and Gary Jonah was scared because Gary was big and strong. I would start pretending to do things and also I would tell lies to get my way in even though I would get in trouble for it.
I do think it is a trap. A reason why is because they have all the survivors from the plane except for Daniella McCarthy. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would be freaking out and trying to get as much information as I could before something bad happens. I would try to leave as soon as possible once I had enough information about the other survivors.
I definitely think that the conference is a trap because the conference is just for Liston, Clarksville, and Upper Tyson. And when they were separated into different group in one group it was almost all 36 babies that were on the plane. (Except Daniella McCarthy she didn’t come.) When Mr. Hodge was calling names, every time when Katherine heard a name that was the names on the list that she had remember then she would squeeze Jonah’s arm. If I was Jonah, half of me would run for it, but the other half would be prepared if later on something would happen. Katherine, Chip, and Jonah just went to the conference just to talk and meet the kids on the survivors. Jonah parents didn’t want Katherine to go, but Jonah told his parent that Katherine should come because Katherine could feel the horrors she avoided by getting birth parents who were crazy enough to keep her.
Ben Utz I don't really know if it is a trap or not. In my opinion I think that they are just trying to get all the kids back to where they belong. another possibility is that they are trying to capture them and do testing on them. If I were in Jhona's shoes I would just run away.
In my mind the whole get together is going to be a trap. One of the reasons why it is a trap because e could grab Jonah or chip. Another reason why is that all the children from the plane there. These are the reasons why it is a trap
Yes, I think it's a trap. I think it's a trap because I think it's too much of a coincidence that the adoption meeting is for adopted children who are from Liston, Clarksville, and Upper Tyson. All the kids who are on the survivors list are from those locations. Even Katherine realized the coincidence. If I was Jonah, I would be very alert of my surroundings. Also I would look out for any important details.
I believe that it is a trap. I believe it's a trap because what are the chances they would sort all the kids they saw on the survivors list in one group. I know they're all in one group because it says in the text, "Mr. Hodge called out every single one of the nineteen names we know, even Dalton Sullivan, who has to be the Dalton on our list." If I was in Jonah's shoes I would try to talk and explain to the kids the situation. I wouldn't make a big scene unless something out of ordinary happened.
In my opionion, I believe that it's a trap because Mr.Hodge called most of the 36 kids in his group. The other reason I believe that they are going to take tests on the all the kids. Another reason that I believe it's a trap is because they took all the babies from the plane except one. To me that is really weird. Why would they get all the babies that were on the plane except Daniela MaCarthy?
In my opinion, I think that it is a trap. I think that it is a trap because Mr. Hodge called out every name that Chip, Katherine, and Jonah knew and more. So, that could mean that Mr. Hodge had all 36 kids in his group except for Daniella. According to the text Chapter 25 states, "Katherine pulled the name tag off her shirt, and crumpled it in her hand." Katherine did this because she wanted to make sure that she was in Mr. Hodge's group with Jonah and Chip. If I were Jonah right now I would just keep myself quiet and split up with Chip and Katherine. I would do this because then I could get a chance to meet the other kids and if Mr. Hodge was a government agent I wouldn't want him to know that I was a part of the scene in the library with Angela.
I do think it is a trap all those names from the list and thirty-six names called and thirty-six babies it is definitely a trap. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would try to get the most information I could but do it secretly and quickly. After I got the information I would try to get out as fast as I could because if it was a trap set by either Jb or E I still have wanted to get out just in case. I would have gotten out one of three ways Ask to go to the bathroom and instead sneak out, pretend to be sick and you have to leave, or Just sneak out without anyone knowing.
Caden McKnight Based on what I read I think that it is a trap. I think it is just too suspicious that all the names they recognized went into one group and that the group has roughly thirty six kids. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would play along and act normal. I would still be very cautious and careful.
Teon Erwin This whole situation is clearly a trap. Everything seems too coincidental to be true. All the names that Jonah had recognized had all been in one group. He needs to stay calm, so the people don't know that his caught on to them. Jonah needs to just play along at wherever they are getting at.
I think that it is a trap. I think this because what if E got there and got them. JB wouldn't be able to help them. Who knows where he is? If I was in Jonahs shoes I would probably be doing the same thing he is right now. I would be wondering if the government or the FBI were in everything and I would be panicking. I wouldn't go to the thing that they were going to. I don't think that it matters if it is sponsored by the county it matters if it's safe.
ReplyDeleteMakayla Shawcroft
ReplyDeleteI think that this is a trap because weird have been going in the book since Angela left. None of the Dupre people have never even heard of Angela Dupre. Also when Chip and the others went to Robin's Egg Lane they met a woman that said that the house that Daniella said she was going to move into was a house that had been empty for a long time. If I was in there shoes first I would try to first remember all the facts that I could about James Reardon because it seems that he is included in this whole mess because he seemed to know were the people were going to be move before the people even knew they were going move. Then Chip figures out a pattern that all the adoptions kids. They are all now located in Upper Tyson, Clarksville, and Liston which happen to be the areas that the kids can come and talk adoption in a meeting. Then after I thought about all that I think that I would probably go because maybe I could figure out E's plans or I could tell the other survivors the latest updates on what has happened.
Brandon Calkins,
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, I think it would be a trap because of the way Mr. Hodge deals with the kids. If I were in Jonah's place right now, I would run away from the adoption place with Katherine and Chip to find out where E is and what he's trying to do with his plans, and if Angela is with E. Then I would track down Angela to see if she is alright and in good condition. As for the parents, they could go home or they would probable follow me Katherine and Chip.
I think it is a trap, because Mr.Hodge picked out the kids on the survivor list. He also picked out 36 kids. This could mean that he is trying to kidnap the kids or kill them. I believe that Mr.Hodge is E. Or maybe someone who E works with. But I still believe my theory about E being good. So maybe this man is against E. Trying to sabotage everything. If I was Jonah, I would try to pick up sharp rocks on my way to the picnic. So I would have a little to defend myself, if anything happened. If I saw anything suspicious, I would try to contact 911 as soon as possible. But I would try to keep low key as well. Because maybe if I stay close to Mr.Hodge I might find useful information
ReplyDeleteI think that it is really cool that Katherine pretended to be Daniella. I think that I would have done the same thing.
DeleteIn my opinion, I think it would be a trap because of the way Mr. Hodge handles the kids. He picked out 36 kids on the survival list. I would think that he would harm them. I would not trust them.
DeleteI think that it is a trap,and Mr. Hodge could be working with E. Plus, he gathered up all of the children that were on the plane. I think that Mr. Hodge may kidnap them, because he shut the doors, possibly locking them. This separates the children from their parents. That means that if they get kidnapped, there would be no one to save them. I think that if I were in that situation, I would play it cool until I find out what was going to happen. I of course would be scared on the inside, I just wouldn't show it.
ReplyDeleteDakota Sasser
ReplyDeleteI think it is a trap to. but I have a theory. I think e sent the notes to lead them in to a trap. Back to the subject. If I was in there shoes I whould be peronoid be couse I don't know who sent it.
Abril Ugalde
ReplyDeleteFrom my reading, I know that they possibly have every single kid that was on that plane 13 years ago other than the girl Katherine replaced. I do think that it is a trap, I just do not know what the trap is. What could they possibly do with 36 13-year-old kids and come up with an explanation?
If I were in Jonah's shoes, would slowly walk away with Chip and Katherine. I would hide so they couldn't see me and watch what they were doing. If things got out of hand and it was a trap, I would sprint back with Chip and Katherine to warn all of the adults.
Addison Hollister
ReplyDeleteI do not think it is a trap. I think it is just a coincidence that the babies were in the same group, maybe they're not even the same babies from the plane. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would be scared, but not of the fact that the babies on the plane are in the same group, but of everything else going on around me. I wouldn't show it, because you would need to stay calm for Chip and Katherine so they don't start freaking out and panicking.
Parker Jones
ReplyDeleteI think it is a trap. I think that Mr. Hodge is going to kidnap the kids that he called into the lobby. Jonah is in a panic because his sister is in the other group of kids and not with him and Chip. I think Jonah is going to try and get Katherine out of the other group and into the same group as his so they can be together. If I were in Jonah’s shoes I would want Katherine to be with me too. I would also try to get all of us kids back to our parents before something bad happens to us by Mr. Hodge or Carol.
Gavyn Renfro
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion I think it is a trap.I think that Mr.Hodge sent the letter to kidnap of of the kids on the survivor list.If I were in Jonah shoes I would want Katherine to go to the other group.I would not think it would just be a cowincadence that all the survivors are inthe same group.
From my reading, I think it is a trap because Mr. Hodge had every kid on the survivors list. I think that he might be working with "E" and he is planned on taking all those kids back to their time. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would act, I would ask Mr. Hodge what we're doing. I would have asked what our plans for the day were. I think that everyone there works for, or with, "E". I think that Mr. Hodge or Carol is going to try and get the kids to leave the school so they can send them back to their time.
ReplyDeletei would call for help and find war the trap is at.and save my ferns form E.
ReplyDeleteYes I think it is a trap to get all the kids from the plane together for E. If i was in Jonahs shoes i would probably follow them and on any sign of trouble i would turn around and run. I also think that they sent the letters to them. Also that they also are trying to send them back to there time.
ReplyDeleteCasamaro White
ReplyDeleteBased on what I read, I believe it is a trap ever since Angela left more things have went down hill than normal. The Dupree's have never even heard of Angela Dupree is what surprises me most. I also think that Mr.Hodge is helping E because he had every kid on the survivors list. Also that they will both take all the survivors back to their time. Jonah is in a panic right now because his sister is in another group of kids and not with him and Chip. I have a feeling Jonah might sneak out of his group to get Katherine and bring her to his group. If I was in Jonah's shoes I would be doing a lot of the same things he is doing right now. I would go get Katherine to stay with me in my group just in case something bad happens. I would also try to sneak to the door and open it for the parents to see if anything bad happens they can step in.
Taylor Alvarez
ReplyDeleteI do not believe the conference is a trap. I do not think it is a trap because there are other adopted kids there. I do think that Katherine should not have pretended to be Daniella McCarthy. I think she will get caught if they ask her questions only the real Daniella knows the answers too. That is part of the reason why Jonah has panicked. If I was in his shoes I would just keep quiet and go along with the conference but I would be panicking too. I would be hopeful that Katherine has a plan and that all goes okay.
I think that the conference is a trap. Some people are very sneaky like they can knock someone out in one punch with other people in the room without them even noticing. If I was in Jonah's shoes I would call the police. (if they will rely on me).
ReplyDeleteLily Pinson
ReplyDeleteTo be honest, I do think that it is a trap. I think this because at the end of chapter twenty-five, they had almost all of the babies from the plane. In my opinion, I think that this could be the point where they had all been rushed into a time traveler that could disguise itself as anything you could think of and go back in time. Yes I do think that the time traveler that the babies were on could disguise itself as anything you could imagine. Although, if I were in Jonah's shoes, I would want to run away with Katherine and Chip. I would not care who these people were. All that I would know is that these are people that I don't know, and that they seem suspicious and I should get out of there as soon as possible. I would let the police know where other kids are located with no supervision of any other adult what so ever. I would want to make sure that all of the other kids would be safe from harms way.
Johnanthony Hallberg
ReplyDeleteI think its a trap because mr.Hodge is probably going to kidnap all the children on the survivors list. And the reason I think that he will kidnap them is he is working with "E" so "E" can do what he wants with them. Also if I was in Jonas shoes I would run away with chip and katherine. and ones I got away I would call the police and tell them where I am and what happened. and ones I was safe I would retrace my steps and see if I could find out where they went
Brielle Johnson
ReplyDeleteI think that the conference is a trap. Ever sense the meeting with Angela things have been weird. Mr. Hodge and CarolI think is helping E because all the kids on the survivors list is there. The Depres didn't know Angela. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would act. I would go ask Mr. Hodge what they were going to be doing. As I was walking around I would try to find things to defend myself incase something happened.
Lainey Hyde
ReplyDeleteI think that the meeting is a trap because there where all 36 kids from the plane at the meeting. What are the odds of that happening. If I where in Jonah's shoes I would have gone to the meeting but made my mom and dad stay so if it was a trap they could do something. In conclusion, I do think that the meeting is a trap.
Thane Horton
ReplyDeleteYes I think that conference is a trap. I believe this because, all 36 of the survivors are there with Mr.Hodge and none with Carol. I think Mr.Hodge and Carol work with E. It has also been weird since the meeting with Angela. If I was Jonah I would group up with Chip and Kathrine to talk to all the kids.
Rafe Card
ReplyDeleteI think it is a trap. It is a trap because they are going to get kidnapped with E and Hodge. They are with all the 36 survivors together. This seems really fishy because the people with carol are not any of the 36 people that where in the plane.
Kenadee McKnight
ReplyDeleteI think it is a trap. I think it is a trap because they have all thirty-six kids there together. I think that they are going to take them somewhere and show them where they came from. This confrence is not an adoption confrence. This is going to show them who they really are.
Haelie Adams
ReplyDeleteI do think that this is a trap. I think it is a trap because they ALL got the letters and I think that they are ALL being asked to go. If I was Jonah I would not go. I would stay home with Chip and Katherine and see what happens if they do not go.
Evelyn O’Neill
ReplyDeleteFrom reading chapters 23, 24, and 25 I think that it is a trap and they could get hurt. If I was in Jonah’s shoes I would not done all that he has. If I did something wrong I know that JB would help me. If I did do everything that he did I would be more and more into it.
John Rowe
ReplyDeleteI think that it is going to end up being a trap. I think that E is going to be there and try to get info from them just like at the library. If I was in Jonah's shoes, I would have told them that something didn't feel right, and that they had to leave that place before something bad happens. If I were Jonah, I would have been alert and ready to act too.
I believe that this is a trap. Its very odd that while Jonah, Chip, and Katherine are trying to look in the adoption stuff, and then a paper shows up for adoptees to figure out their identity. Another thing that is very odd is that the guides made all of the kids on the Survivors list. What I think gives the guides away the most is that each kid has to touch a certain part of a rock, which is supposedly a hand scanner to make sure you are who you say you are. If I were Jonah, I would have been ready to act and I would also be more alert than he is.
ReplyDeleteClayton Rigney
ReplyDeleteThings are getting a little scary. I do think it could be a trap. But it also is a perfect time for Jonah and Chip to get information from all the kids on the list. If I were in Jonah's shoes I'd get all the information as fast as I could.
I think it's a trap! Why would it happen to only be in the three towns of the survivors? It can't be a coincidence that it's for adopted children and the children of those specific towns only. I think they need to warn someone about this meeting such as the police or Jonah's parents.
ReplyDeleteSofia de la Cruz
ReplyDeleteI think that it is a trap that all of the children were put together in a group. I think that the E will be coming in the next couple of events. If I were in his shoes, I too would be stressed. I think that even though he might be stressed or panicked he should stay.
Zowie Anderson
ReplyDeleteI think that it is a trap because E might be sponsoring it. I think that it was for Upper Tyson, Clarksville, and Liston and those are all where the survivors adopted kids moved too. So I think that E is going to try and kidnap or do something with the kids that are adopted.
Graycee Tibbals
ReplyDeleteI think it is a trap.I think this because what if the E went there and got them.JB wouldn't be able to help them.Who knows where he is?If I was in Jonahs shoes I would probably would be doing the same thing right now.I would be wondering if the government or the FBI where in everything.I would want to go to where they are going.I don't care if it is sponserd by the county or to be safe.
Tylie Norcutt
ReplyDeleteI think it is all a trap. If I were in Jonahs shoes I would be freaking out. I would be wondering what is going to happen next. I would also be wondering who all know about this. Is it just the FBI or does the government know too.
I believe that it is a trap. If I was in Jonah's shoes I would be calm ant thinking of a way to escape or just think of a way to shut it down or fight it. I think that the F.B.I set it up because Mr.Reardon figured out that Jonah had taken pictures and met with Angela and he was trying to stop Jonah. I also wander if JB knows about it so he can go help Jonah, Chip, and Kathrine.
ReplyDeleteRafe Brown
ReplyDeleteI feel that it is a trap for a couple of reasons. One reason is that Angela said there were thirty-six babies on the plane and Katherine said that Mr. Hodge called 36 kids in his group and Katherine told Jonah they were all the kids on the plane. I don't think that it's a coincidence that all 36 of the kids on the plane are in the same group. E or someone is plotting something. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would try to maintain myself and figure out a plan in case something really was going to happen. I would also be asking all the kids questions about any strange events that had been happening lately.
I like that you are on alert and already have a plan started. That's smart!
DeleteLevi Johnson
ReplyDeleteI think it's a trap and that if I were in his shoes I would scared and nervous. I would do a couple of things. First I would learn some sort of defense skill. Second thing I would do is keep watch of every body and make sure one tries to capture me.
I do think it is a trap because it is no coincidence that Mr. Hodge called all thirty-six kids that were on the plane in his group. I also think it is a trap because I think Mr. Hodge is E. I think this because Mr. Hodge wouldn’t call all thirty-six kids on the survivors list in his group; he would only call all of them if he wanted to get them all together to do something to them. If I was in Jonah’s shoes, I would stay close to Katherine and Chip to make sure that we all stay together. Also, I would make sure that we are all protected by one another. Another thing I would do is stay at the back of the line so if Mr. Hodge tries to do something to us; Katherine, Chip and I could get away.
ReplyDeleteI think it is a trap, it's kind of weird that Mr. Hodge called thirty-six kids up to his group and there was thirty-six babies on the plane. I think that Mr. Hodge is E, and if he was I would try to get everyone out of there (including the kids I don’t know.) If I were Jonah I would send Katherine into the other group just in case anything happens she would not be involved. But then yet again Katherine would probably refuse and come with us any way.
ReplyDeleteCarter Paul
ReplyDeleteI think it is a trap, because Mr. Hodge picked out the kids on the survivor list. He also picked out 36 kids. This could mean that he is trying to kidnap the kids or kill them. I believe that Mr. Hodge is E. Or maybe someone who E works with. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would have gone to the meeting but made my mom and dad stay so if it was a trap they could do something.
Avery Paul
ReplyDeleteBased on what I read, I think that it is a trap and they could get hurt. If I was in Jonah’s shoes I would not done all that he has. If I did something wrong I know that JB would help me. If I did do everything that he did I would be more and more into it.
According to the text, Mr. Hodge called up thirty-six children. It isn't just a coincidence that that happens to be the number of babies on the plane. I think that Mr. Hodge is E and that all of this is a trap! What if he is planning to take them back to the future, or even harm them physically? If I were Jonah, I would make sure I was as far away from Mr. Hodge as possible, and close to Katherine and Chip. This could be a life or death situation. Who knows what his parents would be thinking?
ReplyDeleteKennadee Irving
ReplyDeleteI completely think that is a trap. There is 36 kids on the plane and 36 kids in the line. All the kids on the survivors list got called into the same line. I mean it can’t be a coincidence. Mr. Hodge is probably an accomplice of “E”. Kathrine, Chip, and Jonah are walking straight into a trap.
Jarrett Peek
ReplyDeleteBased on what I have read I think that it is a trap because Mr. Hodge picked out all of the kids on the survivors list. There were also 36 babies on the plane and there are 36 kids in line. I think that Mr. Hodge is E or works with E.
Aubrey Vaughn
ReplyDeleteI think that it's a trap. Just because the government held the event doesn't mean that the event was safe. It's a trap because all thirty-six kids were in the same group. If I was in Jonah's shoes I would have gone. I would know something was wrong. I would also panic because I know that Mr. Hodge is E.
Jessalyn Lewis
ReplyDeleteFrom my reading I believe that it is a trap. I believe that it is a trap because in the text it said
“ Angela said that there were thirty-six babies on the plane. I think Mr. Hodge called out thirty-six names.” This tells me that someone had planned to have all thirty-six of the kids in one group. Since they are all in one group, people like E can do whatever they want with the kids. If I were in Jonah’s shoes right now, I don’t think that I would feel any different then he does right now. I would find a reason to leave and hide until three o’clock.
Lily Lawson
ReplyDeleteI think that could be a trap. Or the gathering of all these kids has some purpose. If I was Jonah, I would feel scared and panicked that something might happen. I believe that they will find out the information they need to solve the mystery.
Mattie Zulz
ReplyDeleteFrom my reading, by now to me it seems obvious it's a trap based upon how the 3 kids (Mostly Katherine) thought that it possibly could be a trap. Back tracking a bit, 36 babies were on the palne. Mr. Hodge called out 36 names, names of kids that are all adopted, half of them on the survivors list they got pictures of. At this point in the book, everything is comming together. If I was in the situation Jonah was in I wouldn't know what to do, but I know I would definetly not be as courageous as him. I'd rather curl up in a corner and scream until someone did something. Maybe that's not a good thing but I do not have enough courage at all to do something like with Jonah did.
Preston Kelsey
ReplyDeleteThinking about what I read I think it is a trap. They want all 36 kids in one place. If they are all trapped in one place E can do almost anything to them. I would feel panicked and scared like Jonah is in the book. E is a stranger and strangers can be dangerous as I had said before. If I were Jonah I would want to go and face the challenge, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't feel very scared. I like what John Wayne said about courage. "Courage is being scared to death and saddling up anyway."
Isaac Matinez
ReplyDeleteI think it is a trap. I thought that it was strange that they called thirty six names including the ones on the list. If I were in Jonah’s shoes, I would be panicking. In my head I would be thinking that James Reardon and E are going to pop out and take all the kids. I’m sure that this is what the letters were warning them about.
Chapter 23,24,25
ReplyDeleteRUBY HISKETT
I believe the whole thing is a trap. One of the people managing the whole thing could actually be E. If I was Jhona I would actually shutting the whole thing down. I would not want to go to a big convention and meet people that I didn't even know. If I was Jhona I would also be freaking out as well, all of this would be very scary to me.
I really think that it is a trap because there was 36 kids on the plane and thirty six kids in a list so it has to be a trap. If I were Jonah I would also be freaking out. I would also try to cancel this entire thing. I would think that Mr.Readon and E are going to try and seek all of the kids to the future. Over all, if I were Jonah I would be very scared and would not want to go on.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBased on what I read I think it is a trap. First there were 36 seats on the plane and there are 36 kids in a group all being on the plane besides Katherine. I think Jonah isn't ready to act yet. if i was in his shoes I would have tried to slip away from the group and get to my parents before something bad happened.I would be very scared too.
ReplyDeleteZane Felton
ReplyDeleteBased on information I got from these chapters, I would be a little suspicious about the event. Either way, I would still go to the event to find more answers. I would really think it would be a trap when 36 kids including me would be put in a group. Like Angela stated at the library, there were 36 seats on the plane. At that point if I was in Jonah's shoes, I'd panic.
Ava Ekins-Faught
ReplyDeleteBased on what I read, it sounds like a trap. There were thirty-six babies on a plane and now there are thirty-six kids that are all adopted in the same group, and they are also all on the survivors list. When Chip, Katherine, and Jonah were at the library Angela said that she thought that there were from the future. She also said there were thirty-six seats on the plane. If I were Jonah I would be worried.
Bryce Adams
ReplyDeleteFrom what I have read it does sound like a trap. Mr. Hodge could be working with E. There was 36 babies on the plane but, Mr. Hodge called 36 kids to the plane. I would ask the kids if anything has been going on that has been weird.
Anna Springfield
ReplyDeleteAccording to my reading I think that it is a trap. It is the perfect set up to have. I think that one of the people who manages could be E. If I were Jonah I would be nervous. I would be putting myself in danger and not knowing what was going to happen and in that situation I would be very nervous.
Serenity Achurra
ReplyDeleteI think that it is a trap. It is a possibility that Mr. Hodge could be working with “E”. If It was me I would also have a panic feeling. I would to get more information before I did anything. Other than that I would pretty much do the same thing as Jonah.
Sofia Utz
ReplyDeleteI believe this is a trap. I think this because the only people he called were most likely all the people on the plane. I also think this because if you remember all the letters, one of them read "Beware! They're coming back to get you!", and this situation seems like the perfect time to retrieve all the people of the people on the train. If i was in Jonah's shoes, I would follow along, just to see what would really happen, though this can be a bad idea because it could get to where i can't escape, I would try this just to see what would happen.
Gabby Stiehl
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion I think this is a trap. I think it's a trap because if Katherine's theory that all 36 babies were separated into the same group, it must be because Mr. Hodge is working with E. If I were Jonah I would be scared and confused. I would probably want to just go home and forget about the whole situation. I think Jonah should just sit back, stay quiet and observe.
Amillia Nguyen
ReplyDeleteI think it is a trap because Mr. Hodge almost called all 36 kids to be in his group from the survivals list or from the witness list. If I was Jonah right now I would try to be prepared for anything that is going to happen next. Another thing I might do is scream or run for my life if something bad is happening. I would do this if I were Jonah because I want to be cautious but scared and frightened. Chip, Jonah, and, Katherine doesn’t know where Mr. Hodge and Gary are taking them and far they will go plus how long they are going to take to go there stay and go back. It might be a trap because when they met Mr. Hodge and Gary Jonah was scared because Gary was big and strong. I would start pretending to do things and also I would tell lies to get my way in even though I would get in trouble for it.
Colin H
ReplyDeleteI do think it is a trap. A reason why is because they have all the survivors from the plane except for Daniella McCarthy. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would be freaking out and trying to get as much information as I could before something bad happens. I would try to leave as soon as possible once I had enough information about the other survivors.
Nathalia Nguyen
ReplyDeleteI definitely think that the conference is a trap because the conference is just for Liston, Clarksville, and Upper Tyson. And when they were separated into different group in one group it was almost all 36 babies that were on the plane. (Except Daniella McCarthy she didn’t come.) When Mr. Hodge was calling names, every time when Katherine heard a name that was the names on the list that she had remember then she would squeeze Jonah’s arm. If I was Jonah, half of me would run for it, but the other half would be prepared if later on something would happen. Katherine, Chip, and Jonah just went to the conference just to talk and meet the kids on the survivors. Jonah parents didn’t want Katherine to go, but Jonah told his parent that Katherine should come because Katherine could feel the horrors she avoided by getting birth parents who were crazy enough to keep her.
Ben Utz
ReplyDeleteI don't really know if it is a trap or not. In my opinion I think that they are just trying to get all the kids back to where they belong. another possibility is that they are trying to capture them and do testing on them. If I were in Jhona's shoes I would just run away.
In my mind the whole get together is going to be a trap. One of the reasons why it is a trap because e could grab Jonah or chip. Another reason why is that all the children from the plane there. These are the reasons why it is a trap
ReplyDeleteI would think it was a trap but just in case I would sit it out and see what happens, or just to be safe I would run away in fear of being kidnapped.
ReplyDeleteMacray O'Neill
Corbin Rollano
ReplyDeleteYes, I think it's a trap. I think it's a trap because I think it's too much of a coincidence that the adoption meeting is for adopted children who are from Liston, Clarksville, and Upper Tyson. All the kids who are on the survivors list are from those locations. Even Katherine realized the coincidence. If I was Jonah, I would be very alert of my surroundings. Also I would look out for any important details.
Emily Bird
ReplyDeleteI believe that it is a trap. I believe it's a trap because what are the chances they would sort all the kids they saw on the survivors list in one group. I know they're all in one group because it says in the text, "Mr. Hodge called out every single one of the nineteen names we know, even Dalton Sullivan, who has to be the Dalton on our list." If I was in Jonah's shoes I would try to talk and explain to the kids the situation. I wouldn't make a big scene unless something out of ordinary happened.
Anehli Aguilar
ReplyDeleteIn my opionion, I believe that it's a trap because Mr.Hodge called most of the 36 kids in his group. The other reason I believe that they are going to take tests on the all the kids. Another reason that I believe it's a trap is because they took all the babies from the plane except one. To me that is really weird. Why would they get all the babies that were on the plane except Daniela MaCarthy?
Sarah Polish
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, I think that it is a trap. I think that it is a trap because Mr. Hodge called out every name that Chip, Katherine, and Jonah knew and more. So, that could mean that Mr. Hodge had all 36 kids in his group except for Daniella. According to the text Chapter 25 states, "Katherine pulled the name tag off her shirt, and crumpled it in her hand." Katherine did this because she wanted to make sure that she was in Mr. Hodge's group with Jonah and Chip. If I were Jonah right now I would just keep myself quiet and split up with Chip and Katherine. I would do this because then I could get a chance to meet the other kids and if Mr. Hodge was a government agent I wouldn't want him to know that I was a part of the scene in the library with Angela.
Hunter McNabb
ReplyDeleteI do think it is a trap all those names from the list and thirty-six names called and thirty-six babies it is definitely a trap. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would try to get the most information I could but do it secretly and quickly. After I got the information I would try to get out as fast as I could because if it was a trap set by either Jb or E I still have wanted to get out just in case. I would have gotten out one of three ways Ask to go to the bathroom and instead sneak out, pretend to be sick and you have to leave, or Just sneak out without anyone knowing.
Caden McKnight
ReplyDeleteBased on what I read I think that it is a trap. I think it is just too suspicious that all the names they recognized went into one group and that the group has roughly thirty six kids. If I were in Jonah's shoes I would play along and act normal. I would still be very cautious and careful.
Teon Erwin
ReplyDeleteThis whole situation is clearly a trap. Everything seems too coincidental to be true. All the names that Jonah had recognized had all been in one group. He needs to stay calm, so the people don't know that his caught on to them. Jonah needs to just play along at wherever they are getting at.